I guess I shouldn't have been surprised that my request for winter cycling tips did not attract suggestions: to buy a Saab with heated seat warmers or to move to Mexico. Nor did anyone suggest having a little brandy in a hip flask for those moments when you have to wait for a long red light.
Earnest bunch, you.
Nonetheless, I would say that the responses to my request have covered the gamut of smart things to think about when you cycle-commuting this winter. Here's a rundown of what was said, with my own suggestions factored in.
For the bicyclist:
Dress for conditions: One Irish rider, who gets more rain than snow, opts for Gore-Tex, but we don't get that much rain-snow mix here. I have found that a slippery fabric is better to prevent snow from sticking to you: jacket and tights. Wool socks and overbooties keep the feet warm. My Louis Garneau neoprene boots are warmer than my Sugoi polyester top-covers, but neither is much good if you have to put your foot down in an icy puddle. One boot suggestion was the Keen waterproof.
Get lobster mitts, which have the added benefit of preventing you from giving anyone the finger. If you aren't into tights (Assos winter bib tights were recommended), try snowboarder pants, which tend to have cargo pockets and ankle tighteners. I've found that a simple long-sleeved shirt under a jacket (with underarm zips) is enough for my upper body, but if body temp is an issue, consider a light fleece vest under your jacket. You can always unzip
Of course, wear a helmet, but if you don't want to wear one of those lightweight under-helmet noggin-covers, consider a helmet cover (less of an option if you have a helmet mounted mirror or light). Get a half-face mask. Seirus was recommended. You can cover your lower face, or tug it down to act like a scarf when you heat up. You can get one for between $15 and $20. A good investment.
Dress to be seen (no ninja, said Plam): Look for tights with reflective stripes. Go for bright-coloured jackets or vests. If you can, pick up some reflective tape at your local Len's Mills store or notions shop and sew on some strategically placed strips.
For the bicycle:
I can't tell you how comfortable I am on studded tires. Recommended was the Nokian Mount and Ground W160 and Nokian A10, but I bought cheapie Innovas. Yeah, there's more drag with studs. But yeah, you can achieve forward motion and control in bad conditions. Inflate just slightly less than recommended: gives you more surface area of tire, and if your studs are widely spaced, ensures there is contact.
Full fenders: They help keep the snow and slush off you and the bike's working parts.
Pedals: I'm off two minds about clipless pedals. I use them, and have fallen twice in the winter. I do find they give me a better sense of control, but you can't get out of them instantly. Your choice.
Be seen: Applies to the bike, too. The Highway Traffic Act requires a steady white light in the front and a steady red one in the back, but once you have fulfilled the requirements, use blinking lights fore and aft -- the slushy crap that gets thrown onto car windshields makes it all the harder for motorists to see you. Be visible. I stick a red Turtle-type light in the back of my helmet. If I could run Christmas lights up and down the seat stays, I would. Recommended was the Schmidt SON generator hub (a costly retrofit for most of us).
BE CAREFUL
Yes, it's our road and we have a right to a share of it. With bicycle lanes full of snow and snow-slowed drivers already irritated, discretion may be the better part of valour in some cases: take the streets less travelled, rediscover bike trails, use sidewalks if you have to (fewer peds now, anyway).
For more tips on winter cycling, check out this website for the City of Toronto's Bicycle User Group.
One of the best recommendations came from Bruce, who advised that cycling isn't always about purposeful riding: get out and ride for fun. Tow your kids on their magic carpets. Ride on a frozen creek. Follow a snowmobile track. This is Canada. It's winter. Have fun.